deviant art

Deviant Login Shop  Join deviantART for FREE Take the Tour

Changing the race/ethnicity of movie characters ( cause of this [link]! , wich i think is pretty stereotyped itself, but still) 

36%
183 deviants said sometimes i care, sometimes i dont, depends on many factors. (such as; if its whitewashing, if the original character was a real person etc..)
31%
159 deviants said Is not ok. characters should be portayed as they are supposed to be from the book, or other media they were taken from for the movie. Cast directors should not take liberties, its offesnive.
15%
75 deviants said In some stories is it way more important that original charactes races are mantained, than others. Also, some characters share this " no other race should be allowed" characteristic.
10%
52 deviants said i dont care, al long as the actors can act the part and reflect the character's personality and issues etc..
3%
14 deviants said People should not care so much about this. lets just enjoy movies.
1%
7 deviants said Its not a question if they are able to do it legally, but a moral issue. (explain, maybe)
1%
7 deviants said A director should be able to take a story and model it as they want (as long as not offensive i guess), even if that includes racebending, and not be moraly crucified for doing so.
1%
7 deviants said oh man, thats a sensitive issue, Why the heck would you do a poll about this topic?! (i dont think is such a terrible question really)
0%
2 deviants said Its ok, i guess, movie companies have no legal obligation to cast characters with the original race of characters taken from books or else, to make their movies (in some cases, i think)
0%
1 deviant said Sure it is ok, Bollywood does it all the time! and no one complains.

Devious Comments

:iconalura-the-sage:
~Alura-the-Sage Jun 23, 2012  Hobbyist Writer
Normally, I don't think it matters. HOWEVER, in movies where there are supposed to be several different races of people, the actors ought to be of varied races. For example, the the movie The Chronicles of Narnia: Prince Caspian, the Telmarines seemed to be played by mostly Spanish actors as opposed to the British actors for the people in Narnia.
Reply
:iconalura-the-sage:
~Alura-the-Sage Sep 1, 2012  Hobbyist Writer
*in the movie
Reply
:iconnaomicb:
~naomicb Jun 22, 2012  Student Traditional Artist
This is tough. I mean, I would be slightly ticked if they white washed any race of character, or even vice versa. But at the same time, I don't really care about skin color whatsoever.

I guess my thing would be changing the character that was originally for something Hollywood thought would be better. Like giving Katniss more feelings for Peeta than she actually had. haha. But TECHNICALLY KATNISS was "olived skinned" as the book says. Now, I imagined her as some type of mixed race but I wasn't particularly upset when she came out pale as the moon in the movies.
Reply
:iconrainbowxwalrus:
I don't appreciate it because hollywood has consistently requested specifically white actors to play roles that are obviously not caucasian. Casting should be less narrow minded so people like me have someone similar to look up to in films.
Reply
:iconrandom-nessie:
Pienso que depende mucho en el trama, la importancia de raíces o géneros en el cuento, etc. Si no importa, está bien, pero si toda la gente de un país (por ejemplo) necesito ser sólo un raíz, o si el género es central a la personalidad de un carácter, no debe cambiarlos. Pero depende mucho en la situación. :/
Reply
:iconcrazysneakygurl23:
~crazysneakygurl23 Jun 21, 2012  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
If somebody's race or appearance is specified in the original story, I think it should be left alone to maintain authenticity. However, if a character's race is never really pointed out as a defining factor of their characterization (physical, cultural, or anything else), I don't think it matters if a director changes their racial background.
Reply
:iconsurelychoo:
~surelychoo Jun 21, 2012  Student General Artist
Depends on many factors. If race and each one's culture is not important to or specified in the storyline, then I don't mind it. However, when the entire plot is based on a specific race, such as Orientals in Avatar: The Last Airbender, then I would have expected Asians to play in the movie. Changing the characters all to white, while still maintaining Asian clothing, offended a lot of people.
Reply
:iconfujii-chama:
well, I prefer they portray the characters as original like the books as possible.
example: it's not funny to see Chun Li without Asian face (if you change it into a blonde girl, it'll be weird. lolz), or what if you just change Thor / Loki, with its already defined background characters and all with some black guy (No Offence intended).
or Harry Potter, the books says he had messy black hair and green eyes, but you change it into a chopped blonde hair blue eyes.
what do you think?

the creator do create and brainstorm the making-up-the-characters with deep 'personality' and suddenly changing it is weird for me.

imagine you're in the creator's chair. you 'create' and 'raise' your characters, and some guy, with profit-minded brain suddenly change your character to his liking.
Reply
:iconjennis233:
Too Many liberties:
M Knight Shamalan's The Last Airbender
Dragonball Forever
Reply
:iconru-shin:
~ru-shin Jun 21, 2012  Student General Artist
I selected "Sometimes I care, sometimes not" because to me the more important factor is acting ability and getting the story and character growth right. If the character's race plays a big role in the story, then you shouldn't change it. Like in Avatar the Last Airbender. I thought race was important and they should not have changed it. Their races were as indicative to what nation they were from as the clothes that they wore. I also don't approve of just picking white actors cause its easier. If there is an actor of the appropriate race that is an excellent at their job, choose them. Don't be a lazy ass and not even look.
Reply
Add a Comment:
 

Poll History